diff --git a/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/patches/spoof/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.java b/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/patches/spoof/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.java
index 299ff96d9..ef9d62ae7 100644
--- a/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/patches/spoof/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.java
+++ b/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/patches/spoof/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.java
@@ -23,6 +23,8 @@ public class SpoofStreamingDataPatch extends BlockRequestPatch {
             BaseSettings.SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_PO_TOKEN.get();
     private static final String VISITOR_DATA =
             BaseSettings.SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_VISITOR_DATA.get();
+    private static final boolean SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION =
+            SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA && BaseSettings.SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION.get();
 
     /**
      * Any unreachable ip address.  Used to intentionally fail requests.
@@ -67,11 +69,11 @@ public class SpoofStreamingDataPatch extends BlockRequestPatch {
      * Skip response encryption in OnesiePlayerRequest.
      */
     public static boolean skipResponseEncryption(boolean original) {
-        if (!SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA) {
-            return original;
+        if (SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION) {
+            return false;
         }
 
-        return false;
+        return original;
     }
 
     /**
diff --git a/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/settings/BaseSettings.java b/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/settings/BaseSettings.java
index 50f6058a0..004766e99 100644
--- a/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/settings/BaseSettings.java
+++ b/extensions/shared/src/main/java/app/revanced/extension/shared/settings/BaseSettings.java
@@ -41,6 +41,7 @@ public class BaseSettings {
     public static final EnumSetting<AppLanguage> SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_LANGUAGE = new EnumSetting<>("revanced_spoof_streaming_data_language", AppLanguage.DEFAULT, new AudioStreamLanguageOverrideAvailability());
     public static final BooleanSetting SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_IOS_FORCE_AVC = new BooleanSetting("revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc", FALSE, true,
             "revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc_user_dialog_message");
+    public static final BooleanSetting SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION = new BooleanSetting("revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption", TRUE, true);
     public static final BooleanSetting SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_STATS_FOR_NERDS = new BooleanSetting("revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds", TRUE);
     // Client type must be last spoof setting due to cyclic references.
     public static final EnumSetting<YouTubeAppClient.ClientType> SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA_TYPE = new EnumSetting<>("revanced_spoof_streaming_data_type", YouTubeAppClient.ClientType.ANDROID_UNPLUGGED, true);
diff --git a/patches/src/main/kotlin/app/revanced/patches/youtube/utils/fix/streamingdata/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.kt b/patches/src/main/kotlin/app/revanced/patches/youtube/utils/fix/streamingdata/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.kt
index 4c5579b1f..3b573061f 100644
--- a/patches/src/main/kotlin/app/revanced/patches/youtube/utils/fix/streamingdata/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.kt
+++ b/patches/src/main/kotlin/app/revanced/patches/youtube/utils/fix/streamingdata/SpoofStreamingDataPatch.kt
@@ -61,6 +61,10 @@ val spoofStreamingDataPatch = bytecodePatch(
 
     execute {
 
+        var settingArray = arrayOf(
+            "SETTINGS: SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA"
+        )
+
         // region Get replacement streams at player requests.
 
         hookBuildRequest("$EXTENSION_CLASS_DESCRIPTOR->fetchStreams(Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/util/Map;)V")
@@ -327,6 +331,8 @@ val spoofStreamingDataPatch = bytecodePatch(
                 ONESIE_ENCRYPTION_FEATURE_FLAG,
                 "$EXTENSION_CLASS_DESCRIPTOR->skipResponseEncryption(Z)Z"
             )
+
+            settingArray += "SETTINGS: SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION"
         }
 
         // endregion
@@ -339,9 +345,7 @@ val spoofStreamingDataPatch = bytecodePatch(
         )
 
         addPreference(
-            arrayOf(
-                "SETTINGS: SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA"
-            ),
+            settingArray,
             SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA
         )
     }
diff --git a/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/host/values/strings.xml b/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/host/values/strings.xml
index dae622313..e239b6781 100644
--- a/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/host/values/strings.xml
+++ b/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/host/values/strings.xml
@@ -2066,6 +2066,14 @@ Tap the continue button and allow optimization changes."</string>
     <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc_user_dialog_message">"Enabling this might improve battery life and fix playback stuttering.
 
 AVC has a maximum resolution of 1080p, Opus audio codec is not available, and video playback will use more internet data than VP9 or AV1."</string>
+    <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption_title">Skip Onesie response encryption</string>
+    <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption_summary_on">"Skip Onesie response encryption.
+
+• Fixes a new type of playback issue that some users are experiencing.
+• AV1 codec may not be available."</string>
+    <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption_summary_off">"Do not skip Onesie response encryption.
+
+• Some users may experience a new type of playback issue."</string>
     <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds_title">Show in Stats for nerds</string>
     <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds_summary_on">Client used to fetch streaming data is shown in Stats for nerds.</string>
     <string name="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds_summary_off">Client used to fetch streaming data is hidden in Stats for nerds.</string>
diff --git a/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/xml/revanced_prefs.xml b/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/xml/revanced_prefs.xml
index c73dcf55a..be91eb852 100644
--- a/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/xml/revanced_prefs.xml
+++ b/patches/src/main/resources/youtube/settings/xml/revanced_prefs.xml
@@ -831,7 +831,12 @@
             <ListPreference android:entries="@array/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_type_entries" android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_type_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_type" android:entryValues="@array/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_type_entry_values" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />
             <app.revanced.extension.youtube.settings.preference.SpoofStreamingDataSideEffectsPreference android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_side_effects_title" />
             <SwitchPreference android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc" android:summaryOn="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc_summary_on" android:summaryOff="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_ios_force_avc_summary_off" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />
-            <ListPreference android:entries="@array/revanced_language_entries" android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_language_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_language" android:entryValues="@array/revanced_language_entry_values" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />
+            <ListPreference android:entries="@array/revanced_language_entries" android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_language_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_language" android:entryValues="@array/revanced_language_entry_values" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />SETTINGS: SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA -->
+
+            <!-- SETTINGS: SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION
+            <SwitchPreference android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption" android:summaryOn="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption_summary_on" android:summaryOff="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_skip_response_encryption_summary_off" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />SETTINGS: SKIP_RESPONSE_ENCRYPTION -->
+
+            <!-- SETTINGS: SPOOF_STREAMING_DATA
             <SwitchPreference android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds" android:summaryOn="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds_summary_on" android:summaryOff="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_stats_for_nerds_summary_off" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />
             <PreferenceCategory android:title="@string/revanced_preference_category_po_token_visitor_data" android:layout="@layout/revanced_settings_preferences_category" />
             <app.revanced.extension.shared.settings.preference.ResettableEditTextPreference android:title="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_po_token_title" android:key="revanced_spoof_streaming_data_po_token" android:summary="@string/revanced_spoof_streaming_data_po_token_summary" android:inputType="text" android:dependency="revanced_spoof_streaming_data" />